Gloriana talks about how she stopped to look things up along the way through the readings. This can be a good habit to develop. It’s a way of taking control of your education and connecting your interests and curiosities to the course material. Like many of us, she talks about the simultaneous revulsion and attraction for violence. It shows us something about human nature, and maybe something about ourselves. Does it help us offload some of our darker impulses?
Seth draws a distinction between violence and crime, which fed Thursday’s discussion. Another thing we talked about was Shecter’s decision to leave out gangsters from True Crime. We’ll be looking at both gangsters and nonviolent crime in this course, so it’s nice that these discussions come up early.
Sara highlights Schecter’s line that “America was from the beginning fertile ground for true narratives of crime.” I like how that parallels Ellroy’s opening line from American Tabloid: “America was never innocent.” We’ll read some Ellroy later in the semester.
A good question would be why has it been fertile ground? We talked some about how the state, or some power, defines crime, and also about Hobbes’ idea of the Leviathan, the state power that keeps us safe from each other. Did America’s democracy foster crime by putting limits on state power?
Someone else (Is it Lindsay? I’m still working on figuring out everyone’s names) talks about the relationship between media and violence – “Imagine if we had no TVs.” That can be difficult, from our media-saturated perspective. But until the twentieth century, there was no video. There was no audio. We’ve always had stories though, through word of mouth, through song, and through print. Did stories have more impact in the old days, when they had less competition? Or do they have more impact now that they’re in HD and surround sound?
There are still some blogs with the default header and/or default title. I encourage people to personalize it a little more. Unless bright orange and yellow balloons actually reflect your vision of true crime…